The Differences Between Shinobu’s and Bonney’s Powers in One Piece

 

In One Piece chapter 1023, Shinobu used her abilities to age Momonosuke by 20 years.

This moment reminded many readers of Jewelry Bonney, a character known for her power to manipulate age as well. While their abilities seem similar at first glance, they are actually quite different. Here’s a closer look at the key differences between Shinobu’s and Bonney’s powers in One Piece:

1. Bonney’s Age Manipulation Is Reversible, While Shinobu’s Is Permanent

Jewelry Bonney has demonstrated the ability to make herself appear older or younger at will. She can not only age people but also revert them back to their original state.

In contrast, Shinobu’s technique causes permanent aging. As she warned in chapter 1021, the transformation she performed on Momonosuke cannot be undone.

2. Bonney Can Make Targets Younger or Older, While Shinobu’s Ability Only Ages

Bonney’s power offers full control over a target’s age, allowing her to either de-age someone into a child or age them into an elder.

On the other hand, Shinobu’s ability only moves forward — she can accelerate the aging process, but she cannot make someone younger.

3. Shinobu’s Powers Affect Objects and Terrain, Bonney’s Are Limited to Humans

Another key difference lies in the scope of their abilities. Bonney’s powers have only been shown working on humans so far.

Meanwhile, Shinobu can apply her aging technique to inanimate objects as well. She once used it to rapidly decay the ground, creating an escape route for herself and the Straw Hat Pirates during their battle against Kaido.

 

In summary, while both characters manipulate age, the mechanics and effects of their powers are significantly different.

Given these differences, if Momonosuke ever wanted to return to being a child, he might need to seek help from Bonney. However, considering that Bonney’s transformations appear to be temporary, it’s unclear if this would be a viable solution.

What are your thoughts on the differences between Shinobu’s and Bonney’s abilities? Let us know in the comments!

SEVENKIX ANIME